Should a Jury Be Allowed to Hear Questionable Testimony by a Defendant?

Should a Jury Be Allowed to Hear Questionable Testimony by a Defendant?

To be sure, the circumstances surrounding the case of Jorge Barahona are cringe-worthy. That said, should a jury be able to hear the statements he gave police when he was heavily medicated and not thinking clearly?

In early 2011, Barahona was arrested in Palm Beach County after his pest control truck was found on the side of I-95; next to the truck, he was found unconscious, his daughter’s dead body was found wrapped in plastic, and his adopted son was found convulsing, allegedly caused by the ingestion of harmful checmicals.

As our criminal defense lawyers know, when police visited Barahona in the hospital to ask him questions about the alleged crimes, he waived his right to an attorney and gave statements to the police. Here’s the problem: he had just been brought out of a coma and was not thinking properly, a result of the fact that he was being heavily medicated at the time.

The 5th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution says that defendants shall be provided a right against self-incrimination; in other words, someone on trial for a crime does not have to testify against him or herself. This principle has been accepted to mean that testimony provided by a defendant in improper or illegitimate circumstances should not be shown to a jury, as it would be a form of the self-incrimination on the part of the defendant.

In the Barahona case, his defense lawyer argued that the testimony he gave to police at the side of his hospital bed should absolutely not be allowed in the courtroom when the case goes to trial. According to them, his decision to waive his right to speak with an attorney and the content of his testimony were heavily influenced by his lack of complete awareness; he had just been removed from a coma and was still heavily medicated. As such, he was not of sound mind to make the decision to waive his right or to speak to facts of the case.

Unfortunately, the judge disagreed, claiming that the fact that Barahona waived his right was enough to show that he was “intelligent” in making his statements, and that his mental capabilities were not impaired.

Our criminal defense lawyers know that being medicated, and certainly just arising from a coma, can have a huge effect on how you answer questions and how you think about the consequences of your acitons. Would you trust the statements given by someone who was on a great many controlled substances? Probably not. Why, then, is the judge in this case allowing the testimony given by the then-medically-drugged Barahona to be played before a jury when this case goes to trial?
The fact that Barahona has been accused of such heinous crimes probbaly has something to do with it. The fact is, though, that the law should be objective; while he may face charges stemming from disgusting circumstances, he is deserving of the rights afforded him under the U.S. Constitution.

Our experienced criminal defense lawyers at the Law Offices of Leifert & Leifert fight hard for the rights of our clients. If you have been charged with a crime in Palm Beach, Broward or Miami-Dade County, call our skilled lawyers at 1-888-5-DEFEND (1-888-533-3363) to schedule a free consultation. We have the experience and knowledge to help you prevail in your criminal case; we look forward to speaking with you about how we can assist you.

Palm Beach Gardens
  • Palm Beach Gardens
  • 800 Village Square Crossing
    Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
  • Wellington
  • 12230 Forest Hill Blvd
    Wellington, FL 33414
  • Ft Lauderdale
  • 507 SE 11th Ct
    #500
    Fort Lauderdale, FL 33316
  • West Palm Beach
  • 2101 Vista Parkway
    #1006
    West Palm Beach, FL 33411
  • Delray Beach
  • 2160 W Atlantic Ave
    2nd Floor
    Delray Beach, FL 33445
  • Plantation
  • 1200 S Pine Island Rd
    #220
    Plantation, FL 33324
  • Boca Raton
  • 2255 Glades Rd
    #324A
    Boca Raton, FL 33431
Get Direction
  • Boca Raton
  • 2255 Glades Rd
    #324A
    Boca Raton, FL 33431
iboca-raton-location
Get Direction
  • Plantation
  • 1200 S Pine Island Rd
    #220
    Plantation, FL 33324
Plantation-location
Get Direction
  • Delray Beach
  • 2160 W Atlantic Ave
    2nd Floor
    Delray Beach, FL 33445
Delray Beach
Get Direction
  • West Palm Beach
  • 2101 Vista Parkway
    #1006
    West Palm Beach, FL 33411
west palm beach location
Get Direction
  • Ft Lauderdale
  • 507 SE 11th Ct
    #500
    Fort Lauderdale, FL 33316
Ft Lauderdale
Get Direction
  • Wellington
  • 12230 Forest Hill Blvd
    Wellington, FL 33414
Wellington
Get Direction
  • Palm Beach Gardens
  • 800 Village Square Crossing
    Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Palm Beach  Gardens
Palm Beach  Gardens
Wellington
Ft Lauderdale
west palm beach location
Delray Beach
Plantation-location
iboca-raton-location